Skip to main content

Table 7 Concerns with policies on donation after cardiocirculatory death in children's hospitals in the United States, Canada, and Puerto Rico [142].

From: Donation after cardiocirculatory death: a call for a moratorium pending full public disclosure and fully informed consent

Topic of concern

Examples

% of protocols

Death determination

Pulselessness can be determined by palpation alone (a highly inaccurate method [161, 162].

14%

 

No specification of method to determine pulselessness.

11%

 

No specification of duration of absent circulation until organ harvest.

10%

 

Fewer than 5 minutes of absent circulation until organ harvest.

10%

Conflicts of interest

Transplant personnel are precluded from declaring death.

88%

 

Transplant personnel are excluded from premortem donor management.

51%

 

Physicians caring for potential organ recipients are excluded from participating in premortem donor management or declaration of donor death.

32%

 

If the family raises a question about organ donation, donation after cardiocirculatory death can be discussed with the family prior to a withdrawal of life support decision.

21%

Premortem interventions

Premortem interventions are prohibited.

3%

 

Premortem heparin is used.

55%

 

Premortem vasodilator(s) are used.

18%

 

Premortem vessel cannulation is used.

36%

 

Consent is required for premortem interventions.

75%

Palliative care of donor

Medication intended to hasten death is precluded.

44%

 

Withdrawal of life support occurs only in the operating room.

54%

 

Of those having withdrawal of life support in the operating room, the family is allowed to remain until death is declared.

48%

 

The family is permitted to view the body after organ removal.

27%

Voluntariness of consent

The family can withdraw consent at any time.

16%