Absent circulation is irreversible at 2-10 minutes | Absent circulation is not irreversible at 2-10 minutes |
---|---|
Permanent is a reasonable 'construal' of irreversible. | The ordinary meaning of irreversible is 'not capable of being reversed.' Permanent is not a 'construal' of irreversible at all. |
There is a moral/legal obligation not to resuscitate. | Irreversible is not a moral/legal concept. The obligation to or not to resuscitate is due to the patient being alive. Death is a state of a body, and those in exact states cannot be both dead and alive. |
There is no difference in outcome by waiting for irreversibility. | This admits that permanence is a prognosis of death, not a diagnosis of death. The DCD donor is living (even if he/she may be dying). |
Autoresuscitation does not occur after 65 seconds of absent circulation. | This is based on inadequate data (n = 5), and tries to explain away the Lazarus phenomenon. |
Permanence accords with accepted medical standards and the intent of the law. | This is misleading and inaccurate. This ignores ontologic and moral issues. This mischaracterizes accepted medical standards. The intent of the law was not 'permanence'. |
Brain death is not required to diagnose death. | The intent of the law is that there is only one death per person. DCD donors are not brain dead. |